COMMUNICATIONS & TECHNOLOGY AD HOC COMMITTEE

October 20, 2010

 

** NOT APPROVED **


Members Present:  D. Pullen, M. Healy, J. Scott, and C. Crandall

 

Absent:  M. Johnsen

 

Others Present:  F. Sinclair, K. LaForge, J. Margeson, T. Miner, M. Alger, T. Ross, B. Rigby-Riehle, R. Hall, Sheriff-Elect R. Whitney, S. Torrey, M. Saia, K. Hooker, D. Lavery, and R. Zink     

 

Call to Order:  The meeting was called to order at 10:01 a.m. by Chairman Dave Pullen.

 

Approval of Minutes

A motion was made by Legislator Healy, seconded by Jerry Scott and carried 4-0; w/1 absent, to approve the minutes of July 21, 2010.

  

OLD BUSINESS / UPDATES

 

Ackerman  Hill Tower / Support Building

Mike Saia reported he will be responsible for the installation of the new tower.  The status to-date is the majority of the tower is finished in the fabrication shop with half being galvanized.  He is meeting the foundation contractor today and excavation will start within the next two weeks.  He has the layout of property and is now looking for direction from the county on site location for installation.  Legislator Sinclair asked that the new tower be put as close to the existing tower as possible.  M. Saia commented there is concern with existing guide wires and access by the crane and they will put the tower just outside the interior fence line, so as not to disturb the guide wires to first tower.  Legislator Sinclair asked of original guide wires could be removed to allow tower to be installed inside fence.  M. Saia will work around wires to avoid building a new fence, but he has to work around the crane as well, as safety to the original tower and guide wires is critical.  There was discussion regarding cost to put tower inside original fence or possibly removing one side of fence so tower is in the perimeter of triangle.  The outer fence will not be affected.  Dig NY will be onsite for UFPO layout.

 

There was consensus that Russ Hall of Fire Service will be the contact person for Mike Saia.  County Administrator John Margeson reported that he met with M. Saia last week and he recommends that M. Saia and R. Hall do initial site inspection and if there are any concerns, to let him know and the County DPW will follow-up.  There was committee consensus that this process was acceptable and they will accept what is found to be appropriate by J. Margeson and R. Hall.  Chairman Pullen entertained a motion for the committee to authorize John Margeson, County Administrator, to make decisions based on recommendations by Mike Saia and Russ Hall.  Motioned by Legislator Healy; seconded by J. Scott and carried 4-0 w/1absent.       

 

There was discussion regarding the construction of a new support building to house tower equipment.  M. Saia reported he can provide, at no cost to the county, a stand-alone cabinet building that is temperature controlled to store the equipment.  This will be a temporary structure until such time the County can fund the construction of a new building.  The county will have to supply the power to cabinet.  It is not in the best interest to house the equipment in the current building, as it will be a fire hazard.  His temporary cabinet is more secure than the existing building in place.

 

There was further discussion on the cost for a new building and the proposal for a turn-key 12x30 concrete building, temperature controlled, would be approximately $44,850.  This size is adequate for all equipment to be housed.  Equipment has grown and there is no more space in the current structure.  The question was raised regarding a new concrete building versus temporary cabinet.  M. Saia remarked there is no room in the temporary cabinet for anything else.  It won’t support other users to the tower. R. Hall commented a new building provides more versatility.  Future interfacing would create more cabinets to be in place, whereas the new building can house everything.   Chairman Pullen recommended that the committee move to provide a new building as soon as possible.  R. Hall recommended proceeding if funds are available.  It needs to be done, but done right.  Chairman Pullen asked the committee for any thoughts and/or suggestions.  Legislative Chairman Crandall has met with Ways & Means Committee to look into funds available.  There is a possibility to share the cost between 2010 and 2011 budgets.  They will also look into possible funding through outside sources.  R. Hall commented that Allegany County is one of the few counties to have a center set up as a backup, where we can be on-line without help from outside agencies.  He anticipates within the next few years it will become mandated to have backup centers, which could allow for some funding and historically, 911 surcharge and other funding has been made available for these projects.  The cabinet is our backup plan for now.  Chairman Pullen suggested tabling any further action on the new building until such time funding has been established.  C. Crandall suggested the committee compile a list and plan for what will be needed over the next few years, prioritize and get costs, etc.

 

Joyce Hill Tower – The tower will not support the installation of a 3’ dish which is performance based for connection to the SE quad in the county.  Current tower is not capable.  It was suggested replacing the tower with a 180’ self-supporting tower, with a 90 mph wind rate.  The new dish supports Public Safety simulcast system for the county only.  There was discussion regarding the availability of other towers to utilize and it was determined the county should control its own destiny as much as possible by owning their own towers.  R. Hall commented there is no funding available for capital expense in the current PSIC grant, the building is in bad shape and the generator is not in good condition.  The tower site is land-locked with access through a neighbor’s backyard, which works for now, but if property were to sell, there is concern over future access to property.  J. Scott encouraged the need for the county to own its own land for site access.  There is farm land adjacent to current site and it was suggested looking into purchasing land for access.

 

Legislator Healy commented we need an overall perspective of tower usage and formulate a plan to govern it.  We need to access the local law and be informed when new towers are going up.  There was discussion of a creating a Comprehensive County Plan.  Chairman Pullen suggested finding out what other towers are available and plan for the future.  Legislative Chairman Crandall suggested the need for a plan of existing and future buildings, towers, etc. and it should be referred to the County Attorney for investigation.  Chairman Pullen entertained a motion to refer the issue of research of the Joyce Hill property to the County Attorney to investigate.  Motioned by Legislator Crandall; seconded by Legislator Healy and carried 4-0 w/1 absent.   REFER TO COUNTY ATTORNEY

 

 

Communications System / Upgrades – There is the need of a review of the communications systems, upgrades underway, grants in play or future opportunities, existing committees and coordination of efforts with the County Planner.

 

Southern Tier West – Four of six towns have been constructed; Swain, Baldwin Hill, Black Creek area and broadband from Caneadea to Rushford.  There is currently 320-340 customers and a waiting list of 100, which will be addressed with the completion of the Ackerman Tower installation.  They are waiting for reimbursement from NYS to finalize the last few pieces.  Overall, the project is going well with hopes of completion by year-end.  There is $30,000 available for additional antennas.  The Highway Association discussed where they could be best utilized and they are looking at the townships of Alma and Ward.  It was noted there are two towers in the northern part of the county which will be included in this project.  Legislator Sinclair addressed Sheriff-Elect Tompkins and inquired if R. Hall could be utilized on a committee to pull together usage of towers and resources, to which he replied, “yes.”

 

Chairman Pullen commented that if any funding is available, and a tower is available, then funds should be utilized to add equipment versus building a new tower.  They have explored the concept and the hardest part with grant funding is the match.  It is difficult to come by for any county and usually in-kind services are provided as the match (i.e. rental fees).  Possibly work with all three counties (Chautauqua/Allegany/Cattaraugus) at once to address the areas not being served and use the county match for that. 

 

There was discussion regarding coordination of efforts and committees.  Legislator Sinclair suggested to the Chairman and Administrator to investigate such a structure.  Hopefully Southern Tier West will continue to work with us towards these goals.  Chairman Pullen requested suggestions on who should be on this task force.  Legislative Chairman Crandall said he will work with J. Margeson and possibly just have an expansion to this committee.  He also thanked Richard Zink for being here today.

 

A motion was made by J. Scott; seconded by Legislator Healy and carried to adjourn the meeting at 11:02 a.m.

 

Respectfully Submitted,

 

Cathleen L. Whitfield

Recording Secretary